Posted by: Tony Carson | 18 July, 2007

Why Canada should get out of Afghanistan

There are at least 6 good reasons why Canada should get out of Afghanistan.

• The case for war in Afghanistan was never made, Canada simply morphed from peacekeeper to warrior with no real public discussion. As we are learning from another war, if the people aren’t committed and an objective isn’t clearly stated, there won’t be a lot of domestic commitment. Yes, headlines are shouting 50% of Canadians are in favour of the war, but they could just as easily announce that 50% are against it. Because this war has never been properly ‘sold,’ and because it has no clear objective, it has the potentially to be highly divisive — again, like another war.

• As a group NATO countries are not evenly committed to this war; UN troop levels are staying at 36,000 while insurgents grow stronger. If this is truly a NATO initiative it shouldn’t have an opt-in, opt-out look and feel to it, not just to the member nation’s commitment of troops, but even to where they will allow those troops to be send. Canadians, for instance, are in the volatile southern Kandahar region where other member countries refuse to go.

According to a UK report, there is evidence that the Taliban and al Qaeda-linked insurgents are expanding their sphere of influence outwards from the Pakistan safe-haven of Helmand province. There now may well be a demand for greater troop strength at a time when NATO member countries increasingly equivocate about this war. That puts too much pressure on the Committed countries to pick up the slack.

• The inevitable reports from wars like this of the excessive killings of innocents weakens the perception of the West as a responsible agent for change in the region. Indeed, Afghanistan Prime Minister Karzai himself was moved to complain about these reckless killings. As in Iraq, the killing of innocents can result in a heightened call to action of the insurgents.

• Afghanistan continues to be a narco-state with heroine accounting for 30% of Afghanistan’s economy. In fact, poppy cultivation expanded from 104,000 hectares in 2005 to 165,000 hectares in 2006 as NATO fumbles about looking for a way to deal with it.

• But the single biggest reason for Canada to get out of Afghanistan is that it simply is not Canada’s fight, it is first and foremost a Muslim fight and requires long-term Muslim solutions; Canada and NATO countries should only help in the fight at the request of Muslim nations, not take it over.

Afghanistan is just one of many counties brutalized and corrupted by Islamic fanaticism. Before Canada and NATO ever get involved in what are essentially quasi-religious wars, there must be a convincing consensus within the broader Muslim world of the objectives of the so-called fight against the Muslim terrorists. And, as important, there must be full participation of all Muslim countries in these fights. Why should the west fight while the Saudis and Kuwaitis pump oil?

Muslim fanaticism is an enormous problem throughout the Muslim world. But it is a Muslim-first problem and it must find Muslim solutions. The West can and should help where it can but NATO isn’t the answer. Muslims, themselves, are the answer, in Afghanistan, as in Iraq.

Advertisements

Responses

  1. If this is truly a NATO initiative it shouldn’t have an opt-in, opt-out look and feel to it, not just to the member nation’s commitment of troops, but even to where they will allow those troops to be send.

    While I agree that the reluctance of many NATO member states should give us pause, technically no NATO mission requires total consensus or total participation from all member states. Most NATO missions are opt-in, opt-out, for if they weren’t NATO as an organization would never have survived. Any state may decline to participate in a mission with or without comment.

  2. Dear Sam and Tony,

    I wanted to compliment you on your blog and the very insightful pieces here. As well, I’d like to introduce myself, I am an Editorial Researcher for The Mark News (www.themarknews.com) in Toronto.

    I noticed your pieces on Afghanistan and wanted to bring your attention to a number of articles that we’ve just published dealing with the future of the Afghanistan Mission and Canada’s Role in it. Notably, the former Ambassadors to Afghanistan and NATO, as well as the former Vice-Chairman of the CIA National Intelligence Council bring valuable analysis, and I thought you might be interested? You can find the page here : http://www.themarknews.com/topics/4

    We’d be happy to have you publish them on your site, just please link back to us!
    Have a look and let me know what you think.

    Thanks,
    Julie

  3. The current goal of the mission in Afghanistan is not to make war. It is a peacekeeping mission. The majority of Canadians do not understand that we are not in Afghanistan to suppress the Talibans. We are there to train the Afghani army. This way, when Canada will withdraw from Afghanistan, the Afghani army will be capable of providing protection to the nation against the Talibans. This is why we cannot get out of Afghanistan at this moment. We must finish our mission first. If we would leave tomorrow, the Talibans would take control of the nation yet again and all the effort that has been done up to date would be wasted. This would be tremendously wounding for the families of the courageous Canadians who have lost their lives fighting for this cause. Regrettably, all the political parties apart from the Conservatives do not recognize this reality and are desperately fighting to get our troops out of Afghanistan as soon as possible, supporting that we are wasting funds and lives abroad. Do not worry. Unlike the United-States, Canada is not fighting against terrorism, which is useless. Those activists groups will never stop growing, even if you think you destroyed a main hideout and blocked their suppliers. They are continuously recruiting new individuals everyday. We can beyond doubt declare that the United-States are wasting their time and money, but that’s their own problem. All this to say that the Canadian operation in Afghanistan is very reasonable. The Conservatives know what they are doing.

  4. yogabis hello there and thank you for your information – I have definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise several technical issues using this website, as I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous to I c…

    hello there and thank you for your information – I have definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise several technical issues using this website, as I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous to I could get i…

  5. Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.

  6. Nail designs….

    This is a very interesting way to look at taking the initiative and making something happen. Great post….

  7. Nearly all of the opinions on this particular blog site dont make sense.

  8. Although some will be terminology consists through experienced gamers to help place from the amateurs, a number of have been recognized
    terminology inside slotocash entire world of which any newbie trying to help
    it become major ought to know. The particular great issue in relation to online video
    slotocash video games, is actually which whatever version in this common pastime you enjoy probably the most, that is likely to be offered.

  9. Awesome things here. I’m very satisfied to look your post.
    Тhank yоu sо much anԁ I’m having a lοοk forward tо contact уou.
    Will уou ρlease drop mе a mail?

  10. Good way of explaining, and pleasant piece of writing to take information concerning my presentation focus, which i am going to deliver in school.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: